MAY  2007
FATHER KEVIN BATES, SM
FATHER CEDRIC PISEGNA, C.P.
CATHOLICVIEW STAFF

FATHER KEVIN BATES, SM

 

”Does the Penitential Rite clear one of a mortal sin before communion?” - Clara
 

Father Kevin:

Does the Penitential Rite and "Lord I am not worthy to receive You, only say the word and I shall be healed" clear you of a mortal sin before communion? (E.g. missing mass once)  - Clara

Gosh Clara,

I suppose it comes back to what you think God is really like and whether God regards missing Mass once as sufficient to deny you His presence and His love.  The Church's law says that we should confess every sin that is considered "mortal" in the sacrament of Reconciliation.  The Church also teaches that that Penitential Rite in the Liturgy serves to clear our hearts from sin as we prepare for the Eucharist.  The Church still teaches that to miss Mass deliberately on a Sunday is a serious sin and also teaches that some circumstances can mean that missing Mass might not be serious if there were good reasons for doing so, or there were circumstances beyond your control. 

Again, come back to your own personal relationship with God - Would God turn away completely from you for this one event even if there was some element of sin present?  Or does this one event mean that you have turned your back on God completely?  Then I think you will have your answer.   The fact that you are even asking the question means that you are longing to be at peace with God is more than enough of an answer.   Every good wish to you. – Father Kevin

 
”Why do people turn to God only in times of disaster?” - Kelly

Father Kevin:

Hi! My name is Kelly. Just a quick question, why do you believe people turn to God only in times of disaster?  What is your opinion on this topic? Any information that you could give me to with your opinion or the bible's opinion on this topic would be greatly appreciated. Thanks. – Kelly

 

Hi Kelly:

Thanks for your question.  I guess it's a natural sort of thing for this to happen.  We only call the doctor when we are sick, or the lawyer when we are in need of legal help.  In the same way, I think it's possible for people to treat God as a service person that you only call on in times of need.  I can understand how this happens in busy lives, or in lives where God is there on the edge of people's consciousness.  Having said that, to treat our relationship with God in this way really misses the whole point of the presence of the sacred, the presence of God in our lives.  I think the gospel makes it very clear, that our faith is a "boots and all" commitment, and the only way to make sense of a relationship with God is to be on intimate terms with God, to pray constantly and to be in touch with the sacredness of things if you like.  This doesn't necessarily mean we become overly religious - something which often puts other people off!  Rather it does mean that we are deeply in touch with what really matters in life, and of course if this is the case, then God is at the center of things for us and never far away from our awareness.  Every good wish. - Father Kevin

 

”My wife had to have a sterilization procedure for her health.  Am I guilty of mortal sin?” - Darrell

Father Kevin:

My wife had several miscarriages in her early twenties.   She also gave birth to a full term baby that died in her early 20's!  She gave birth to our daughter in her middle 30’s.   According to her, the Doctor advised her she needed a sterilization procedure for the sake of her health, and my wife states she was also advised by a Catholic Priest that it was permissible to get the operation.  Although, I don't doubt my wife’s word in regards to what the Priest told her, I do question some of the new younger Priests liberal views on some laws of the Church.  I feel guilty that she had this procedure.   I was stationed overseas at the time.  I realize that what was done is done and it cannot be reversed, but with more knowledge in regards to the church stand on this matter than I had, since I was a fallen away Catholic in those days, am I guilty of a Mortal Sin for not demanding that she not obtain this operation? - Darrell

 


Dear Darrell:

Firstly, this was your wife's decision, taken while you were absent, and taken on the best medical and pastoral advice she could get at the time.  So how can it be that you are sinning in any way since you were not party to the decision?  My guess is that your wife made this decision sincerely and having sought the best advice she could, and so she is not in sin either.  Again, look to your personal relationship with God and ask yourself in the depth of your heart what God would really think. 

God understands the ambiguities and the complications of our lives much better than we can and is quietly relaxed as we find our way forward.  He's not sitting around waiting to pounce on us because of some error of judgment or some moral failure. You say you feel guilty that she has had this procedure, but again this was her choice, which it seems she made in everyone's best interests and as generously as she could.  Perhaps you need to trust her judgment here and trust in God's goodness in it all. 

I hope you can continue to enjoy and give thanks for your marriage and your life together, and your intimacy which is still a wonderful sign of God's fruitful love, as you have been as fruitful as you can possibly be, given all the circumstances, and I am sure your love is still bearing fruit in your own hearts and the lives of others.   

Just a final thought - in this instance, it's not a matter of playing fast and loose with the law, but putting the law where it belongs according to our Catholic Tradition, and that is at the service of our loving relationship with God.  Every blessing to both of you. - Father Kevin



FATHER CEDRIC PISEGNA, C.P.

”Will all the sins of my past life be revealed at the Final Judgement?”
- Tom

Father Cedric:

I read where a person's life history will be revealed in the General Judgement (Final). I am not proud of my past and am working really hard to change my life and live as a decent person and practicing Catholic. Will all the sins of my past life be revealed at the Final Judgement as I have read in the book I am reading, "The Teaching of Christ"? I have no right to question Jesus' teaching but am bothered by this eventual fact. Thanks. -  Tom

Dear Tom,

The Bible tells us that our deeds will follow us and that at the final judgment “books” will be opened. (Rev. 20:12) Those books reveal our life decisions and deeds. However, immediately following “another book is opened.” That is the book of life. Also, called the Lamb’s book of the living, this book reveals all who are “in Christ.” When it comes to the final judgment it will be revealed that all have sinned and none are worthy. What matters most is, Have we come to Christ, believed in him, accepted him as Lord and received his Holy Spirit? If you have, your sins are forgiven, you have been reborn and God lives within you. You should have no fear of judgment, but believe that God has good things in store for you.  Jesus has died for our sins, was raised for our justification and has sent the Holy Spirit for our growth and assurance. You have indicated that you are trying to turn your life to God.  I invite you to pray to be filled with the Holy Spirit and pray that you know Jesus in a personal way.  You will receive Peace with God and the Blessed Assurance only Jesus can give. God has revealed much to me about the death experience and the judgment to come. I invite you to purchase my engaging book: Death: The Final Surrender.  - Father Cedric:

"Why do very strong feelings of guilt still bother me even after going to confession?" - Eileen

Father Cedric:

Why do very strong feelings of guilt still bother me even after going to confession?  Thank you. – Eileen

Eileen,

First of all, I am glad that you are going to confession!  Many today don’t.  You talk about “very strong feelings of guilt.”  Guilt is a natural heart response when we do something against the will of God.  Therefore it is a built in indicator that something is wrong.  Perhaps you still feel guilty because you love God and you don’t want to sin in this way again.  I have found that the torment of guilt can actually prevent you from sinning in a habitual way again and again.  Because you feel the guilt, stemming from your love for God, you know not to go there again and sin.  In that way, guilt can actually be a good thing.

However, the sacrament of reconciliation ought to be a healing sacrament. You ought to be able to “lay your burdens” of guilt and shame down and leave them. In that sacrament we celebrate your forgiveness and pray that you experience healing. We need healing from the guilt and shame, healing in our relationship with God and healing from the areas of sin themselves.

In addition, many who go to confession do not know how to trust in the blood of Jesus for their forgiveness. The major foundation of the Christian message is that Jesus suffered and died so that we could be forgiven. It is your responsibility to look on the cross and trust Jesus enough to give him your guilt. Beating yourself up endlessly will not merit anything. Jesus wants you to have Peace with him and within yourself.

Lastly, many people are tormented with guilt because of the evil one himself. The same devil who tempts you to sin, continues to condemn you because of it. It is not God who is condemning you. In fact “there is now, no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.” (Ro. 8:1)  I recommend you speaking that and other scriptures out loud out of your mouth whenever you feel this “very strong feeling.” You must trust in what Jesus has done for you over your feelings. God Bless you and bring you healing.  -  Father Cedric

 
”I have a compulsion to take unnecessary risks.  What can I do?” - Jim            

Father:

I am happily married with four children. I have a compulsion to take unnecessary risks. About once a month I gamble and if I lose $200 I stop but I go the next month. Recently I visited a hooker for the first time. It was a risk and I felt a rush but afterward I felt very guilty. I want to stop but I don't want to tell anybody about this. I won't go to a hooker again but I want to stop the gambling or find another way to get that risk rush. What can I do? Jim

Jim,

It sounds to me like you are addicted to “excitement.”  Many people have a hard time being content unless they are entertained, but you have this to a deep degree.    I remember seeing a movie once where the characters (Patrick Swayzee and others) were all young, surfers, skydivers and bank robbers.  They thrived on the adrenaline rush whenever they did something risky.  I’m not sure what the root of this is.  I do know that the sinful side of us is a “gambler” while the spiritual side of ourselves is an “investor.”  You need to discover what the roots of your wanting to take unnecessary risks is.  One way to do that is to go to counseling.  Another way is to join a 12 Step program dedicated to excitement or risk taking.  Unless you surrender yourself to God, your risk taking will probably escalate.  But, if you deal with it now, surrender to God and try to get to the roots, you can recover.   Please make a move and live in God’s will for your life. – Father Cedric

 

CATHOLICVIEW STAFF

”How can we say we have a soul?” - Benjamin


CatholicView Staff:

My question is complex, it is about the existence of the soul and the dignity of the person. I will divide my question into A and B.
A) Recently I was reading about a birth defect called Anencephaly, which is "a cephalic disorder that results from a neural tube defect that occurs when the cephalic (head) end of the neural tube fails to close, usually between the 23rd and 26th day of pregnancy, resulting in the absence of a major portion of the brain, skull, and scalp. Infants with this disorder are born without a forebrain, the largest part of the brain consisting mainly of the cerebral hemispheres (which include the isocortex, which is responsible for higher level cognition, i.e., thinking). The remaining brain tissue is often exposed - not covered by bone or skin." Babies born with this are often born dead, or at most live a couple of hours. Now, do these babies have souls? Why would a loving God, allow a baby to be conceived-making it a human like you and I, but then not give it a chance to live? Moreover, usually a baby with such a condition does not even have a chance to be baptized. So a loving God allows a human being to be conceived, be born and then die immediately!? What justice and mercy is there in that? What about stillborn babies? What purpose did they serve? If our soul is from God, why would God give a soul to someone who will not even be born alive? And if these babies do not have souls, then how can we say that I have a soul? I was conceived in the womb in the same manner of a stillborn, except I lived--god gave me a soul and not him/her? What about babies who die of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome? Lets go further, lets say a baby dies and other than original sin, as a baby it had no chance to perform anything sinful and thus gets God's grace and love in heaven. I did not die as a baby, I've had a lifetime to do both good things and sinful things. Is God not being unfair here by taking away a sinless (or near-sinless) baby to heaven, but allowing me to live for years where I will at least at one point or the other commit an error? Heck, if God took me away when I was 10 months old, I'd be in heaven right now!

B)Also, on the soul, how can we have one? I can understand a spiritual force outside of space and time, but I AM HERE, IN SPACE AND TIME, yet I am told that I have an incorporeal soul. How is something not corporeal, not material, contained in my body? The soul can't just be consciousness, we have scientific answers to how our brain works and how and why people think. Also, sometimes an embryo can divide into two creating identical twins and sometimes two embryos can merge into one. Can a soul split into two souls? Can two souls merge into one? Now of course, I can't ask for scientific evidence for something spiritual/immaterial, but I just don't get how we can have a soul that is responsible for keeping us alive, that can in effect "record" our lives and deeds, but that this soul can be contained in the body, and that we can hold this as true even though we have no evidence that there is something immaterial to our material beings.

I do believe in God, but my mind is boggled by these problems and you know, if God wanted me to ONLY live by faith, He would not have given me a mind to reason. I know I am not treading on new ground and theologians have debated this all before. I do look forward to hearing your response. Thank you for your time and patience and God Bless.

Dear Benjamin:

Thank you for writing to us with your concerns regarding the existence and complexities of the soul.   Your questions were two-fold, yet simple, for we ARE our souls.   Our souls contain everything that is immaterial that is ourselves.  It is our soul that is the basis of love, emotion, imagination, dreams, fulfillment, all the things that are not tangible yet very real.  Now, I don't remember God saying that we should live by faith ALONE.  There is nothing in scripture that says that we live only by faith without using our intellect.  And the purpose of the human lives that do not see earthly life beyond their birth is beyond me but not beyond God's plan.  All I know is that they are just as human as you and I.   Even through the highest human intellect, logic or faith, we can never understand the supreme and infinite plans of Almighty God as to why things happen during this earthly lifetime.   We depend on trust in the Lord's wisdom.   He tells us in Jeremiah 1:5 “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, before you were born, I dedicated you!”  And this continuity to God is never broken, except by man turning away from His goodness.

But I must say this:   why does one presume that human earthly life is better than human heavenly life?   Life is life whether it is on earth or back with the Creator in heaven.  There is no cheating or injustice in the death of an unborn child and someone who lives to 100 years.  Life on earth is wonderful but life in heaven and with the angels and God is something that cannot be explained and is so amazing that our afterlife is our hope and future joy.  Ecclesiastes 11:5 tells us  “Just as you know not how the breath of life fashions the human frame in the mother's womb, so you know not the work of God which He is accomplishing in the universe”.      

This is the answer to both your questions.   Simple.  Not complicated because God is simple:  He is life and love.    - CatholicView Staff

”Can I marry in an Islamic wedding without being excommunicated?” - Michelle

CatholicView Staff:

I have been dating a Muslim man who has asked me to marry him in an Islamic wedding.  I have concerns that proceeding with this so called "ceremony" will excommunicate me from the Catholic Church. I want to continue my Catholic faith and be married in a church someday, but fear that I may be frowned upon for agreeing to this Muslim act. I also fear that the Catholic Church or a priest will never marry me because I have committed a sin.   Is this a sin?  How would we raise children if the church does accept this ceremony and I can receive the Sacrament of Marriage?  Both religions, Catholicism and Muslim, are dominant in this practice as I have heard.   I am very concerned about this and have little time to make a decision. I have been told that this Islamic wedding ceremony is completely verbal and there are no certificates or licensing. Please Help.   Michelle

 

Michelle:

Your marriage will not be valid in the eyes of the Church if you marry your fiancé in an Islamic wedding.   You will not be able to partake of the Sacrament of Communion unless you have had the Sacrament of Marriage within the Catholic Church..  You say you are concerned about this and rightfully so as there are many factors you have not spoken of such as how you plan to raise your children. 

This is a lifetime partnership.  Your husband does not have to become Catholic in order to marry you in the Church.   But in the case of mixed marriages such as you are contemplating, where one party is Catholic and the other is not, further instructions and preparation is required.  The Catholic purpose is to find helpful ways in which the couple can fully express their love and faith with spiritual unity.

Neither partner in a mixed marriage (between a Catholic and a baptized person of another Christian denomination) is required to sign a promise that all children will be baptized and raised Catholic. The Catholic partner signs two statements. (1) "I reaffirm my faith in Jesus Christ and intend to continue living that faith in the Catholic Church." And, (2) "I promise to do all in my power to share my faith with our children by having them baptized and raised as Catholics" - a significantly different kind of promise than the old one generally thought of years ago.

The non-Catholic partner does not sign anything. The priest who is helping the couple prepare for the marriage signs a declaration that the non-Catholic partner is aware of this affirmation and belief of the Catholic party.  The couple then needs to work together to resolve their religious differences without either of them being asked to compromise their consciences. Catholic ecumenical directives emphasize that the church's primary concern in such marriages is to uphold the strength and stability of the indissoluble marriage union and the family life that flows from it. 

Understandably, stability in a marriage is as a rule more easily assured when both partners share the same faith. Toward this end, the prospective bride and groom are encouraged to establish contacts with each other's ministers and learn as much as possible about their partner's religious convictions and practices.

Since both partners may feel serious commitments to their respective religious denominations, they are encouraged to "discuss the Catholic baptism and education of the children they will have, and where possible come to a decision on this question before the marriage." (All these norms are found in the Official Catholic Directory on Ecumenism, 1993, Nos. 143-15 1.)

Please see your priest immediately to clarify these issues.  I am sure you will find an answer that will be satisfactory to both of you. - CatholicView Staff

 

 ”Can my priest deny me confirmation because I use Marijuana?” - Kobus
 

CatholicView Staff:

Do you feel that a priest is justified in not wanting to accept me into the faith due to the fact that I smoke marijuana?  I have been going to classes for more than a year now but my priest says he will not confirm me unless I choose to stop.  It it fair to deny me the blood of Christ? - Kobus

Kobus:

Thank you for your question.  I am so sorry to hear about your addiction to Marijuana and that you are unable to give it up, even for your confirmation.

Marijuana is illegal and to obtain it means that you are breaking the law by buying it.   You are also aiding a dealer to stay in a business that is punishable by law.  Both you and the drug dealer could face serious consequences. 

Any addiction that takes away normalcy is wrong.  Marijuana is psychologically and physically habit-forming, and produces a high in the user.   It affects the brain and causes perception to be distorted, signaling other actions to take place. With this distortion a person is not truly seeing reality.  And so Marijuana is something the Christian avoids for it is a seduction that leads us away from virtue and reality. We are abandoning ourselves and opening doors that can lead to sinful actions.     

We might say that God created wine and Christ drank it so why is it wrong for us to drink it?  But when one becomes a drunkard or addicted to it, it becomes contrary to what the Lord teaches and that is moderation in all things, and the avoidance of things that may endanger us.  Those who use marijuana and alcohol for its mind-altering benefits dishonor God’s purpose.  It detracts from our witness of God in our lives and is a sin, plain and simple. 

Because God created something, it does not give us the liberty to use it as we please.  Altering one’s state of mind, entering into an unnatural high, escaping the issues that are in front of us is morally wrong.  1 Corinthians 6:19-20 states:  “Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, Who is in you, Whom you have received from God? You are not your own.  You were bought at a price. Therefore honor God with your body.”    

If we were to list all of the things that God has created that we humans have misused, the list would be endless. Marijuana is something that leads us away from God.   Our lives and our bodies are a gift to us and we must use them to bring honor and glory to God as we pursue the life Christ wants.  CatholicView Staff

 

“I had four abortions 15 years ago.  Am I excommunicated?” - Renate
 

CatholicView Staff:

I am a devout catholic and Eucharistic Minister. I had 4 abortions 15 years ago and need to confess this. Will I be excommunicated from the church if I do?

 

Renate:

Your confession of past sins will not excommunicate you.   But, I must tell you frankly:  the fact that you participated and procured four abortions for yourself has already put you in the state of excommunication.   Abortion is the taking of human life, even though that human life is unborn, it is contrary to God’s Plan and Will.  Abortion is a clear renunciation of God’s creative power and love and is a deadly (mortal) sin that destroys a person’s relationship with God (and everyone else around you).   The Church has said openly and clearly:   anyone who has procured an abortion, and anyone who participated in the act of abortion by helping the person to go, advising the person to have an abortion, or taking part in the surgical procedure, is automatically excommunicated and cannot receive the sacraments or participate in the sacred liturgy.   Your act automatically excommunicated you from God.  So, your participation in the Church’s ministries is compromised.  You need and must go to confession immediately and renounce your past sins, repent of the abortions you procured for yourself, and heal your relationship with God who is the Creator of life and not of death and with your Church.  Then, in the secret of your heart and in a quiet place, give your entire self and your past to Jesus Christ as your Savior and Lord.  – CatholicView Staff



”How do I ask for forgiveness for something our faith deems a sin, but I’m not sure I do?” -  Debby

CatholicView Staff:

How do I ask for forgiveness for something our faith deems a sin, but I’m not sure I do?

Almost 25 years ago I had an abortion. I was 22, no college degree and supporting my 14 year old Brother. My Mother committed suicide about 4 years prior and my Father was getting married to a woman that treated my Brother very badly. I was working as a receptionist making only $6.00 an hour. I received $280.00 a month from Social Security to support my Brother and received nothing from my Father. Times were tough, but with God’s loving heart my Brother and I survived.

During this time I fell in love for the first time in my young life. Unfortunately the relationship didn’t last long. I was 4 years older than him and he had asked me to marry him, but he was afraid to tell his parents. I pushed and pushed, until I pushed him right out of my life. It wasn’t until after he broke up with me I found out I was pregnant. To be honest with you, I don’t remember if we brought up the idea of marriage again. All that I can remember is him going to the clinic with me to get the abortion. And how sad I’ve been since.

I’m now married to a wonderful man and I have a beautiful Step-Daughter. However, because I didn’t marry until I was 39 we were never able to have children. I have had 4 miscarriages in the past 8 years. Sometimes I believe it is God’s punishment for what I did. But I still think that at the time, it was the right thing to do considering my situation. Being the person that I am, I don’t believe I could have given the baby up for adoption if I had gone through with the pregnancy. Then I certainly wouldn’t have been able to give it a good life. I was struggling just to support me and my Brother. Even though now that I will never give birth to a child of my own, I wish I hadn’t.

I love my family. I love my Catholic faith and church. And I love and believe in our Lord Jesus Christ. And try to walk in his favor. Can God forgive me?  - Debby

Dear Debby:

God can forgive anything!  He will forgive you when you ask Him to do so.  Put your faith in the mercy of God.  Regrets of past sinful actions is a sign of spiritual maturity and the first step in healing your emotional self and your soul.   Abortion is mortally sinful because it takes a human life, yet unborn, and snuffs out that life even before it had the ability to fulfill God’s mission and plan for that life.  Even though you suggest that your decision to have an abortion may have been the right thing at the time, you do not know that.  The baby could have been a blessing at the time and God would have provided for the needs of the child.   You must confess this sin to a priest so that your excommunication from the church can be lifted and you can be truly healed.  Remember, procuring an abortion (and anyone involved in that decision) is an automatic excommunication from the church.  The excommunication can only be lifted by going to confession and repenting of your sin.  I suggest you go to another church away from your parish and talk to the priest there.  Tell him everything that is on your heart.   Then accept with a grateful heart the affirmation of God’s forgiveness for you through the Sacrament of Penance.  Then talk to your husband.  It may be time to adopt a child that needs a loving home that only you can provide (you are not obligated to do this, but it is a suggestion).  May the Lord fill your soul with the peace that comes from His mercy given freely to all who ask Him. – CatholicView Staff


” Are Muslim marriages recognized in the Catholic Church as valid?
- Martin

CatholicView Staff:

I am a Catholic male, 28 years old. I have a Muslim lady friend who has a 7year old kid. She is divorced from her husband, who was also Muslim. She used to be Anglican but converted ten 7 years ago to marry in the Muslim faith. I am currently involved with her in a intimate relationship. We are not having sex but are involved in other things. What I need to know is whether this relationship constitutes adultery of any sort? Since, as far as my knowledge goes, these marriages are not recognized as marriages under God's eyes? Please could you email me a response. God bless.  Martin

 

 Dear Martin:

 Marriages between Muslim and Muslim are considered valid by the church.  Your lady friend, who is Muslim, entered a valid marriage with her former Muslim husband.  Any sexual contact with your lady friend is considered adulterous.  So, what are you going to do?  You do not mention if your lady friend regrets denying her relationship with Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior and is ready to return to Christianity.  If she returns to Christianity, then you can marry her in the church (after repenting and confessing your sins).  She needs to go through an annulment process in the church if you both want to marry with the sacrament of marriage.  If she does not want to return to Christ, then I must tell you that by continuing in this intimate relationship, it might endanger your Christian faith and your salvific relationship with Jesus Christ as Lord. – CatholicView Staff

 

I remarried civilly after my husband deserted me.  Please, can I receive Holy Communion?” - Fran

CatholicView Staff:
 
I have been a Catholic all of my life. I was christened Catholic at Saint Joan of Arc Catholic Church in Philadelphia. I made my Communion and Confirmation at Visitation Church in Philadelphia. I was married in a Catholic Church to a non-practicing Lutheran man. I went to confession and attended mass.

I wanted a big family, but things turned out differently. It took about three years to become pregnant. I was ecstatic when it finally happened. My husband, on the other hand, wasn't so happy (even though we tried to get pregnant for so long). He found a girlfriend and had an affair from the time I was pregnant and even after giving birth. He was mentally abusive to me, letting me know that he did not want the responsibility of being a father or being married. He said he didn't want to be tied down to children. I was devastated. He threw my baby and I out into the street (I didn't even have money for baby food). My daughter was 6 weeks old. If I didn't have family at the time, I don't know what I would have done. My husband was abusive to me and physically threatened our baby. He continued seeing his girlfriend and eventually she was pregnant by him. He wanted his new life with his girlfriend and threw us away. He eventually left his girlfriend and their daughter they had together. He later had 4 other illegitimate children by 4 different women. Taking responsibility for none of his children.

I raised my daughter Catholic, she made her Communion and Confirmation, and turned into a wonderful, fine woman. Thirty years later, I remarried. l didn't get an annulment because I couldn't afford it. I am remarried now (for three years). I have a husband who to good to me and not abusive and a wonderful Father to my daughter, her husband, and a wonderful Grandfather to our Grandchildren(which aren't blood related). But, I have not received communion because I feel it is against my religion (because I remarried), and did not have an annulment before remarrying. I want to stay Catholic. I need to "have the bread and body of Jesus Christ through Communion." I feel so close to God when I receive Communion. As of right now, because of this, I am a lost soul in need of my religion. I want to remain Catholic, but I also need to receive the sacrament. I really don't want to go to another religion, I want to remain Catholic, but, I will do whatever you say. Please give me an answer as to whether I can receive the host or not.  Thank you. Fathers, I will be anxiously waiting for your reply.  Fran Pearce-Achinko

 

Dear Fran:

I am so happy to hear that you found your soulmate in your present husband despite what happened to you in your first marriage. You certainly have a case for an annulment from the church.   Even though you said that you could not afford the suggested donation for the annulment procedure, each diocese usually dispenses the annulment “cost” for someone in great need.  Ask your pastor about this and show him my answer to you.  He will understand and ask your local marriage tribunal to dispense from the administrative costs of the annulment.  I praise God for the love you now have.  Keep going forward.  As you know, until the annulment is completed, you cannot receive communion yet.  But the time will come.  Give thanks to God each day for your blessings and spiritually receive Jesus in your heart at Mass.  At communion time, close your eyes, picture Jesus reaching out to you and holding you in His loving arms, and tell Him to live within you.  He understands your situation and accepts it.  He knows when it is time, you will come back to the communion altar with your family by your side. – CatholicView Staff

 
”Is it wrong to report the criminal activities of one’s family”  - Cheryl

 

CatholicView Staff:

I have a moral question about crime within families. Part of my family is participating in several felony crimes. I am a confirmed Catholic and feel burden deep inside because it is wrong for them to do what they are doing. Is it wrong to report to authorities about their criminal behavior? This could be life changing for them as they would go to prison. I could end up being homeless and worse for telling. Isn't it better to do what is right and tell authorities, clearing my conscious or is it wrong to do this to your family? The priest at my church says to be careful as it could hurt me, to worry about my own wellbeing. Then, he tells me I could write an anonymous letter after telling him that my soul can’t bear to watch or know about crime within my family.  I don't know what is right.  The priest gave two opposite choices. I am lost. Thank you for your blessed time.

 

Dear Cheryl:

We are so sorry that you are facing such a serious situation.  Not only with the guilt of not reporting this criminal information to the authorities, but also with your conscience as a Christian.

To remain silent makes you an accessory to felonious action, and in the eyes of the law will be considered a very grave issue should they find out you knew what was happening within your family and kept quiet.  You cannot withhold vital criminal information that may save lives and put an end to such activity.   You must alert the police to everything you mention in your letter.  You are obligated to report this immediately and let the police deal with it.  You must not close your eyes and pretend you cannot see these horrific things that are occurring. 

When you talk to the police, tell them of your fears and ask them for their protection.  Yes, it is a scary situation that you are facing but as a Christian, you must do the right thing.  Be strong.  Be brave.  God demands it of us.  If death is one of the consequences, so be it.  Better to die a saint and be with God forever than live an entire lifetime in the sin of lying and cover-up.

CatholicView will keep you in prayer.   We are so sorry that you are innocently caught up in this.  Family or not:   crime must be reported.  When things come to us such as this, we must deal with them in a Christian and honest way.  Yes, it is unfair that you face this frightening and dangerous circumstance you find yourself in, but you must be strong.  Pray hard and ask the Lord to give you the strength to do what is right.   Report those who do wrong and endanger others.  Ask the Lord for His protection as you do what He would have you do in this situation.  CatholicView is hoping you can find the peace that can only come when these matters are straightened out.  God go with you always as you go forward with what you know in your heart is the right thing. – CatholicView Staff 


 
”I have an anxiety disorder and could not do   my confessional penance.  What should I do?” - Dawn
 

CatholicView Staff:

I have an anxiety disorder. While in a state of panic I went to confession. My penance was to say a decade of the rosary. I told the Priest that I could not concentrate to do that. He gave me another penance. Two days later I realized what I had done and I called and apologized. He said not to worry that he knew it was due to stress. I am so embarrassed. I cannot believe I rejected my penance. Is there something else I should do? - Dawn

 

Dear Dawn:

Be at peace!   The Lord understands you better than yourself and he understands your anxiety disorder.  You have a wonderful priest who understood your situation by changing the required penance as a sign of your repentance.  If you couldn’t fulfill the original penance, you had the right and obligation to say so.  You did everything correctly!  Be at peace!   The Lord loves you and knows what you are going through. – CatholicView Staff

 
 “What is the protocol for receiving the Blood of Christ when pregnant?” - Karen
 

CatholicView Staff:

I am an Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion. My husband and I are trying to conceive a child. What is the protocol for receiving the Blood of Christ when pregnant? At our parish, the Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion consume the remaining Blood of Christ after Communion. I understand that the priest representing Christ changes the wine into the Resurrected Lord. Therefore, is it acceptable to consume the Blood of Christ when pregnant? Thank you.  Karen

 

Dear Karen:

It is certainly an honor to God that you are serving the Lord by being an Extraordinary Minister of the Holy Eucharist.  As to consuming the remaining communion (the blood of Christ) during your pregnancy, why not ask your doctor if it is wise to do so?  Certainly there are other ministers who can take care of this in the Sacristy.

I do not think a small sip during regular serving of the blood would endanger you.  Then again, you should check with your doctor.   You can always accept the body of Christ comfortably; God will not fault you for refusing the blood of Christ.   Remember, Christ is completely present under either form of bread and wine.   You receive the TOTALITY of Christ either way.   Be at peace.   – CatholicView Staff

 
”Is it disrespectful to wear a rosary as jewelry?” - Paul
 

CatholicView Staff:

More and more I see people wearing rosaries as jewelry. I was curious how the Church felt about this. Even though I am not a Roman Catholic, this practice seems disrespectful to me nonetheless.
Thank you for your clarification.  Paul

 Dear Paul:

I agree with you.  It is disrespectful.  The rosary is an instrument to be used in meditative prayer.  It is not a piece of jewelry. – CatholicView Staff


”Is it wrong for a husband to bring a wife to climax manually?” - Terry
 

CatholicView Staff:

If a wife doesn't reach climax during sexual relations with her husband , is it wrong for him (or herself)to manually bring her to climax?  A priest once told a group of married couple that this was OK. – Terry

 

Dear Terry:

The physical and sexual intimacy shared by a husband and wife in the bonds of marriage are acceptable if it is a sign of mutual love and respect.  Hope this helps. – CatholicView Staff

 
”What does it mean to "perform the work to which the indulgence is attached?” - Frank
 

CatholicView Staff:

I have a question concerning a Plenary Indulgence. In order to obtain one I must:
"To acquire a plenary indulgence, it is necessary to perform the work to which the indulgence is attached and to fulfill the following three conditions: sacramental confession, Eucharistic Communion, and prayer for the intention of the Sovereign Pontiff.  It is further required that all attachment to sin, even venial sin, be absent."  What does it mean to "perform the work to which the indulgence is attached?  Thanks for your help. - Frank

Frank:

The work to perform could simply be a prayer, or Stations of the Cross, or saying the rosary with others in a public forum (like a rosary group).  The work is usually a prayer and it is described in regards to the plenary indulgence. – CatholicView Staff


”Can you tell me how to christen my granddaughter?” - Rhonda
 

CatholicView Staff:

I wish to christen my newborn Granddaughter in my home. I have holy water.  How do I go about denouncing Satan?  A prayer you could give me and how to do a short ceremony.  Thank you so much! God be with you. - Rhonda

Dear Rhonda:

I don’t understand why you want to baptize (as you say, christening) your granddaughter in your home --  outside of the church.  This is not acceptable unless it is a matter of your granddaughter near immediate death.  Your granddaughter must be baptized in a church by a deacon or priest.  CatholicView Staff

 
”What can I do about blasphemous thoughts when they just pop into my head?” - Maureen
 

Catholic View Staff:

Just recently I was praying and a blasphemous thought just popped into my head.  I knew it in my heart and soul to be utterly false and disgusting.   It was nothing I had control over, but I felt absolutely horrible about it.  I went to confession for it, where I was told it was not a sin since I could not fully control it.  I'm constantly trying not to think about it, but the more I try, the more I think about it, thus causing more thoughts of the same type to uncontrollably pop into my head.  I feel absolutely horrible about this.  How can I get past these feelings and move on? –Maureen

 

Maureen:

Intrusive thoughts are very bothersome and cause much confusion.  We all have had at one time or another an intrusive thought that comes and goes.    Thought in itself is not sinful.   Actions are sinful.  So, when the thoughts come and disturb your peace of mind, say, “Lord, I give you this intrusive thought.  Give me your Spirit of peace.”  Soon, your intrusive thoughts will be gone and you will be able to go on with what you were doing.  There is no sin involved in having intrusive thoughts.  Be at peace. – CatholicView Staff

 ”I believe we will be reunited with our pets when we die.  What are your thoughts?” - Liz
 

CatholicView Staff::

There is much controversy whether animals go to heaven. I am 35, attended a Catholic school, and used to be devout. Then I slipped away from my closeness with God. I have had many trying situations in the past two years that have brought me close to God once again. The best example is my dog. She was diagnosed with cancer a few months ago, and through many, many prayers and tears, it looks like her cancer is gone. My love for her has renewed my faith in God. God is very loving, why wouldn't he want the animals he created to go to heaven? There are many near death experiences where people see their pets. One day I also asked God for a sign if animals went to heaven, and later that day I saw a beautiful rainbow. I truly believe we will be reunited with all our loved ones, including pets, when we die. What are your thoughts? - Liz

 

Liz:

God loves all his creation.  He loves the animals!  He made them for us!  In the Book of Jonah, Chapter 4, Verse 11, God states that He values animals very much in this ending verse (and therefore the moral of the story of Jonah), “And I am I not to feel sorry for Nineveh, the great city, in which there are more than a hundred and twenty thousand who cannot tell their right hand from their left, TO SAY NOTHING OF ALL THE ANIMALS.”    All life will be returned to God, and our pets will be returned to God because life itself cannot be destroyed, only changed.   Though the scriptures itself does not specifically say what happens to animals after death (because the scriptures were more concerned about human interaction with God), I personally agree with you that in heaven, our pets who were our support in this life will be there too.  The Church has no official teaching on this subject.  Once again, the Church is more concerned to bring the salvation of Christ to human beings.  Animals don’t need saving since they cannot chose to sin nor are they completely self-aware like humans are. – CatholicView Staff

 
”Is the word Purgatory in the bible?” - Ann

CatholicView Staff:

I wrote a question in the April articles asking about the Rapture and I understand that the word Rapture is not found in the Bible but is the word Purgatory?   If it is I cannot find it anywhere.  Yet Catholics believe in this teaching of the church. - Ann

 

Dear Ann:

First, the rapture is not a biblical concept.   Purgatory, on the other hand, is a concept that has biblical roots.    Simply, purgatory is the condition of the human soul who at the time of death has not completely repented for their own sins.  Before we can go before God, the Holy Spirit cleanses us of everything that stands between complete union with God and us.  That is purgatory.   It is not a place.  Only heaven and hell are places, but purgatory is a process, a state of being purified and saved, so that we can take our place in heaven.   This is made reference to in the Book of Revelation, Chapter 7, Verse 14, “These are the people who have been through the great persecution, and because they have washed their robes white again in the blood of the Lamb, and they now stand in front of God’s throne and serve him day and night in the sanctuary.”   That’s what purgatory is:  washing AGAIN our “robes” in the blood of Christ after our earthly death (we washed our “robes” white the first time in our baptism and acceptance of Christ as our Lord and Savior but these robes got stained through our human sin throughout our earthly lives). - CatholicView Staff

 
”When I worked for my local diocese things were being done contrary to the bishop’s policy.  Should I say anything?” - Steve 

CatholicView Staff:

I have a dilemma.   I previously worked for my local diocese.   While there, my department head did something which I believe was contrary to the Bishop's policy.   I did not say anything, but it bothered me to the point that I left.   Now that I no longer work there, should I say anything to anyone at the diocese about what happened and might still be happening?   Thanks. Steve

 

Dear Steve:

Honesty and "transparency" are the hallmarks of good administration of a diocese these days.  After having the leadership of the church torn apart by recent sexual scandals and how those scandals were handled should be a warning and reminder to be clear and honest in all things.  That is what the Lord demands of all of us.  The sin of omission (meaning not saying anything or leaving out a mention of wrongdoing) is something that cannot be condoned or tolerated in the administration of a diocese.  The bishop of your diocese is trusting you and others with the administration of God's work and the faith of people which is more precious than anything.  You must report any wrongdoing to the bishop immediately.  You should have done that when you were there.  But now that you are separated from the department that you were working for, you are in a "safer" position to talk or write a letter to the bishop.  Report now.   Then, let the bishop and his investigators figure out the details and the veracity of your impressions of your former boss.  May the Spirit of truth guide you in all you do. – CatholicView Staff


”What is the essence of man according to Catholic natural theology, and how does it differ from Aristotle?”  - Mark

 CatholicView Staff:

I know that Catholic theology borrows from Aristotle, and his ideas of essences. For Aristotle the essence of man would be rational animal, and it is that aspect of man which is to flourish, along with the social aspect and other virtues. What is the essence of man according to Catholic natural theology, and how does it differ from Aristotle? - Mark

 

Dear Mark:

Aristotle was a Greek philosopher (384 BC - 322 BC), a student of Plato.  He taught and wrote on a number of topics.  I was particularly fond of his teaching on thinking logically.  Thomas Aquinas (1225 AD - 1274 AD) took Aristotle's teachings and tried to place them within the Christian faith experience.  Thomas Aquinas had his distracters who disliked him using Aristotle's Greek (and therefore pagan) philosophy as a starting point to discuss the mysteries of God and faith.  I must say that I have the opinion that Thomas Aquinas came quite close to explaining the truth of an infinite God in finite philosophical terms.  Aristotle's and Thomas Aquinas' great contribution to the world is the philosophical notion of "natural law" which is still being taught today in civil law, ethics, and theology.  So, even though Thomas Aquinas' theological teachings were informed by Aristotle's philosophy, to say that the Church holds Aristotle's teaching in high esteem would be untrue.  The Bible and the oral tradition of the Church (Magisterium) are the ONLY philosophy and theology of Catholicism.  Aquinas was just another theologian, although a fantastic and unique one, trying to understand God and His mysteries, and finding the meaning of life.  In your question, you asked what is the essence of "man" within the Catholic faith.  The answer is simple and it is contained in the Book of Genesis, Chapter 1, Verse 27:  "God created man in His image; in the divine image He created them; male and female he created them."  The human person's essence is the image of God and that is what makes us different from the animal world.   Aristotle does call the human person a rational animal.  Yes, I would concur that we are a "rational animal" but we are more.   With self-awareness, intelligence, the ability to create and destroy (changing our environment), we are more like God Himself.  The essence of the human person is the image of the divine, yes, to go so far as to say that we are the spirit, image, and life of the divine.  Aristotle did not even acknowledge that God's image is part of a human being.  So, the aspect of the human person that needs to flourish is the divine and the human spirit, not the animal and physical nature.   Our spirituality makes us radically different from animals.  That divine essence in all of us makes us yearn and search for our Creator who is God, the great intelligence of the universe, the great mover of all things (both Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas wrote about this).    That is why the Church has always taught that through our spirituality (practice of the faith of Jesus Christ), we are able to have the tools to control our physical passions and desires and live for God.  The Church emphasizes the spiritual passions of searching for God and His Will (our part in God's eternal plan).  The other essence of the human person is also explained in Genesis, Chapter 1, Verse 31:  "God looked at everything He created and He found it very good."  We are good by nature, very good as a matter of fact.  This is what really separates us from those of the Protestant Christian theology that sees humankind as very bad and evil by nature.  The Catholic Church sees the essence of the human person as very good since we are made in the image of God.  We did not lose our innate goodness because of "original sin."  Original sin blinds us to this eternal truth (and explains why there is evil in the world.)  The Catholic faith and teachings stem from this thought:  we are very good, made in the image of God.  Forgiveness is the ability to move on and learn from our mistakes.   If we are evil and bad by nature (as the Protestant Christian would have it), then forgiveness would be an empty act since nothing could be done for an "evil by nature" creation.  But forgiveness is the acknowledgment that humankind is good and forgiveness can take the blinders of sin away so that we can see our divine innate potential (Jesus died for all sinners so that sinners could see the divine life within them).  That's the whole Catholic faith in a nutshell.  Theologians throughout the ages since the beginning of Christianity have written so much about this subject of the nature of humankind.  The answer here is a disservice to the work of many writers who have tried to explain God and His Plan and Will to us who question.   But I hope that this simple summary can give you a direction in regards to your question.  – CatholicView Staff

 
”Can a Catholic enter a non Catholic Church for a Funeral? - Tresa 
 

CatholicView Staff:

Can a Catholic enter a non Catholic Church, let's say for a Funeral?   Hasn't this old practice been abandoned? - Tresa

 

Dear Tresa:

There is no problem with going to another church for any service, especially a funeral or wedding.   There was a concern in the past that by going to another church of another denomination or religious faith that it would cause a Catholic to leave the church for some “false” teaching.  There is not that kind of insecurity now (Vatican II Council relaxed this past restriction in 1964).  Remember, you are a Catholic and your first allegiance is to the Church! – CatholicView Staff



APRIL 2007 LINK

Please use the link at the top left side of this page
to comment or be added to the mailing list.